Should you replace both garage door springs when only one breaks? In almost every case, yes. On a door with two springs, both springs were usually installed on the same day, have lifted the same door the same number of times, and have used up nearly the same share of their cycle life. When one breaks, the other is often close behind. Professionals replace both garage door springs as a matched set so the door stays balanced, the cables and drums share the load evenly, and you do not pay for a second service call a few weeks or months later. The main exceptions are a spring that failed early from a defect or damage while its partner is still fairly new, and doors that only use one spring to begin with. Either way, spring work is a job for a trained technician because the springs hold enough tension to cause serious injury. Advanced Door is Utah’s #1 rated garage door company: family owned since 1994, 4.9 stars, 30,000+ five-star reviews, and the only company in Utah offering a lifetime warranty on parts and labor. Call (844) 971-3667 for a free estimate.

Last updated: October 2026
You hear a loud bang from the garage, almost like a firecracker. The next time you press the remote, the opener strains, the door lifts a few inches, and then it stops. You look up at the bar above the door and see it: one spring has a gap in the middle, and the other spring looks perfectly fine.
So the natural question is, why replace both? If only one spring broke, it seems like you should only have to pay for one. It is a fair question, and it is one of the most common things Utah homeowners ask us on the phone. The honest answer is that in most cases you should replace both garage door springs, but there are a few situations where replacing one is reasonable. This guide explains the difference so you can make the call with real information instead of a sales pitch.
We will cover how two-spring systems work, why springs wear out together, what actually happens when only one spring is replaced, the exceptions, single-spring doors, torsion vs extension rules, standard vs high-cycle springs, how Utah’s climate shortens spring life, what a proper replacement includes, and how to make your new springs last. If your door is stuck right now, call (844) 971-3667. Estimates are always free.
Safety Warning
A broken spring means the door has lost most of its counterbalance. A typical double garage door can weigh well over a hundred pounds, and the unbroken spring is still under full tension. Do not try to lift the door by hand, do not let the opener keep trying to lift it, and do not loosen any bolts or set screws on the spring assembly. Keep kids and pets away from the door and call a professional.
Table of Contents
- 1. The Short Answer: Should You Replace Both Garage Door Springs?
- 2. How Two-Spring Garage Doors Work
- 3. Why Garage Door Springs Wear Out Together
- 4. What Happens If You Only Replace One Spring
- 5. When Replacing One Spring Can Make Sense
- 6. Single-Spring Doors: Should You Upgrade to Two?
- 7. Torsion vs Extension: Pair Rules for Each
- 8. Standard vs High-Cycle Replacement Springs
- 9. How Utah Weather Wears Out Garage Door Springs
- 10. Why Spring Replacement Is a Professional Job
- 11. What a Proper Two-Spring Replacement Includes
- 12. Questions to Ask Before You Approve the Work
- 13. How to Make Your New Springs Last Longer
- 14. How Advanced Door Helps
- 15. Frequently Asked Questions
The Short Answer: Should You Replace Both Garage Door Springs?
For a door that has two springs of the same age, the answer is yes, replace both garage door springs at the same time. That is the standard recommendation across the garage door industry, and it is what we recommend to our own customers. It is not an upsell. It is a matter of math, balance, and avoiding a second breakdown.
Here is a quick way to think about your situation before a technician arrives:
| Your Situation | Recommendation | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Two springs, same age, one broke | Replace both | The surviving spring has done the same work and is likely near the end of its life |
| Two extension springs (side-mounted), one broke | Replace both | Extension springs are designed to work as a matched pair, one on each side |
| Two springs, one replaced recently, the older one broke | Often replace both | You end up with a mismatched pair either way; a matched set resets the clock |
| One spring is new and failed early from a defect or damage | One may be fine | The partner spring may still have most of its life left; a technician should confirm |
| Door only has one torsion spring | Replace the one, consider two | A two-spring setup can spread the load and is often a good upgrade on heavier doors |
| Springs rusted, stretched, or mismatched from an old repair | Replace both | Mismatched or corroded springs make the door pull unevenly and wear parts faster |
If you are still trying to figure out whether your spring is actually broken, start with our guide to what to do when a garage door spring breaks or the warning signs in 7 signs your garage door spring is about to break.
How Two-Spring Garage Doors Work
Springs do the heavy lifting on a garage door. The opener only guides the door and adds a small push. When the springs are set correctly, a balanced door feels light enough to lift by hand and stays put when you let go halfway. That balance depends on the springs supplying the right amount of force for the weight of your specific door.
Torsion springs (above the door)
Most modern Utah homes have torsion springs. They sit on a steel shaft (the torsion bar) mounted above the door opening. As the door closes, the springs wind up and store energy. As it opens, they unwind and turn the shaft, which turns the cable drums at each end and lifts the door with cables. On many double doors there are two torsion springs, one on each side of a center bracket, and they share the job of lifting the door. Our torsion bar guide and cable drum guide explain each part in detail.
Extension springs (along the tracks)
Older homes and some budget installations use extension springs. These run along the horizontal tracks on each side of the door and stretch as the door closes. They work as a pair, one per side. DASMA’s official spring color code sheet notes that two extension springs are required for the corresponding door weight, which is another way of saying each spring is sized to carry its half of the load. See our extension springs guide for more.
Single-spring and enclosed systems
Some lighter single-car doors and some builder-grade double doors use just one torsion spring. Other doors use enclosed systems where the spring sits inside the torsion tube. These systems use their own specific parts and adjustment methods, so the question of replacing one or both springs depends on the design. We cover single-spring doors in section 6.
Pro Tip
Count your springs before you call. Look at the bar above the door from inside the garage, without touching anything. If you see two coils with a bracket between them, you have a two-spring torsion system. If you see springs running along the tracks near the ceiling on each side, you have extension springs. Snap a photo of both sides; it helps the technician bring the right parts on the first trip.
Not sure which type you have? Our torsion vs extension springs comparison shows both side by side, and the how a garage door works guide walks through the full counterbalance system.
Why Garage Door Springs Wear Out Together
Garage door springs fail from metal fatigue. Every time the door opens and closes, the spring wire twists or stretches and then relaxes. That is one cycle. After enough cycles, tiny cracks form in the wire and eventually the spring breaks. Spring makers design springs for a target cycle life, and standard residential torsion springs are commonly rated around 10,000 cycles.
Now think about a two-spring door. Both springs were usually installed on the same day. Both have been through exactly the same number of cycles, in the same garage, in the same weather. One broke first because of a tiny difference in the wire, a small rust pit, or a slightly different load. That does not mean the other spring is healthy. It means it has not broken yet.
This table shows the simple math. It is theoretical, because real springs are affected by installation, weather, rust, and maintenance, but it shows why springs on busy family garages do not last as long as people expect.
| Door Cycles Per Day | Cycles Per Year | Approx. Years, 10,000-Cycle Spring | Approx. Years, 25,000-Cycle Spring |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 (one trip out and back) | 730 | About 13.7 | About 34 |
| 4 | 1,460 | About 6.8 | About 17 |
| 6 | 2,190 | About 4.6 | About 11.4 |
| 8 | 2,920 | About 3.4 | About 8.6 |
| 10 (busy family, door is the main entry) | 3,650 | About 2.7 | About 6.8 |
If your household uses the garage as the main entry, it is easy to reach six or more cycles a day. At that pace, a standard spring can wear out in well under ten years, and its partner spring is on the same timeline. For more on cycle life, read how long garage door springs last.
Pro Tip
Spring life is about more than cycle count. According to DASMA Technical Data Sheet #190, spring cycle life is affected by more than the number of cycles. Handling damage like nicks, rust that reduces the effective wire area, the wrong spring for the door, an incorrect number of winding turns, improper stretch, doors left open in extreme climates, and lack of lubrication can all shorten spring life. Two springs in the same garage share almost all of these conditions.
What Happens If You Only Replace One Garage Door Spring
Replacing one spring on a two-spring door is not automatically dangerous when a trained technician does it and balances the door correctly. The problem is what usually happens next. Here are the most common results when only the broken spring is swapped.
1. The second spring breaks soon after
This is the big one. Because the old spring has the same mileage as the one that broke, it often fails not long after. That means a second stuck door, a second morning when you cannot get the car out, and a second service visit that could have been avoided.
2. The door is harder to balance
A brand-new spring and a worn spring do not behave the same way. Old springs gradually lose some of their force as they fatigue. Pairing a fresh spring with a tired one makes it harder to get the door perfectly balanced, and the balance may drift as the old spring keeps weakening. An unbalanced door can drift down when open, slam when closing, or feel heavy when lifted. Our garage door balance test guide shows how to check this safely.
3. Uneven load on cables, drums, and bearings
When one side of the system carries more of the work, the cable and drum on that side see more stress. Over time that can lead to frayed cables, a door that lifts crooked, or worn bearings. If your door already sits uneven, see our guide on why a garage door is crooked, and if a cable has already let go, read garage door cable snapped: what to do.
4. Extra strain on the opener
Openers are not designed to lift the full weight of the door. When the springs are not providing their share, the opener works harder, which can wear gears, sprockets, and the motor. That is one reason openers fail early on doors with poor balance. See our opener gear and sprocket guide for the parts that take the hit.
| Factor | Replace One Spring | Replace Both Springs |
|---|---|---|
| Cost on this visit | Lower | Higher, but one trip |
| Chance of another break soon | High if springs are the same age | Low, both springs start fresh |
| Door balance | Harder to set and may drift | Easier to set and holds longer |
| Wear on cables, drums, and opener | Uneven load on one side | Even load on both sides |
| Service visits over the next few years | Often two | Usually one |
| Chance to upgrade spring quality | Limited by the old spring | Can move to a high-cycle matched set |
If cost is the worry, look at the full picture. Our garage door spring replacement cost guide explains what drives the price, and why garage door estimates are so different shows how to compare quotes fairly.
When Replacing Just One Spring Can Make Sense
We believe in honest diagnostics, so here are the situations where replacing only one spring can be a reasonable choice. In each case a technician should inspect the surviving spring before you decide.
- The broken spring was new and failed early. If a spring was replaced recently and broke from a defect, a nick, or an installation issue, while its partner is also fairly new, the partner may still have most of its life left. Warranty replacements often fall into this category.
- The springs were already different ages. If one spring was replaced a year ago and the original spring just broke, the newer spring may be in good shape. Even so, many homeowners choose a fresh matched set so both springs share the same timeline.
- The door has only one spring. On a single-spring door there is no partner to replace. The question becomes whether to stay with one spring or upgrade to two (see the next section).
- A specific outside cause broke the spring. Occasionally a spring is damaged by something other than fatigue, such as an impact or a part rubbing against it. The technician should check the partner spring for the same damage.
Action Step
Before you approve a one-spring repair, ask the technician three questions: How old is the surviving spring? Does it show rust, gaps between the coils, or stretching? Can the door be balanced correctly with one new and one used spring? A good technician will answer plainly and let you decide.
Single-Spring Doors: Should You Upgrade to Two Springs?
If your door only has one torsion spring, you obviously cannot replace both garage door springs. But a broken spring on a single-spring door is a good moment to ask whether a two-spring setup would serve you better. Many builder-grade doors in newer Utah subdivisions came from the factory with one spring sized to just barely do the job.
A properly designed two-spring setup can offer several advantages:
- Shared load. Two springs split the work of lifting the door, which allows each spring to be sized for longer life and puts more even torque on the shaft.
- Smoother, more even lift. Torque is applied from both sides of the center bracket instead of one, which can help the door travel more evenly.
- Room for high-cycle springs. Splitting the load gives the technician more flexibility to choose springs built for a much longer cycle life.
- Less of a sudden failure. If one spring breaks on a two-spring door, the door still has some counterbalance left. It is still unsafe to operate, but the failure is usually less abrupt than losing the only spring.
A conversion is not right for every door. Very light single-car doors may be well served by one quality spring. The technician needs to weigh the door, check the shaft, drums, center bearing plate, and cables, and confirm the new spring setup matches the door’s weight and height. If the door has had paint, insulation, or windows added since it was installed, that matters too. For example, adding insulation or heavier glazing changes door weight; see our insulated garage doors guide for how weight changes affect the system.
Utah Note
In fast-growing areas like Herriman, Eagle Mountain, Saratoga Springs, Syracuse, and the newer parts of Cache Valley, many homes still have the original builder-grade door and a single spring. If your spring broke and the door is the original, it is worth asking about a two-spring, high-cycle setup while the technician is already there. Our builder-grade upgrade guide covers other parts worth checking at the same time.
Torsion vs Extension Springs: Pair Rules for Each
The basic rule (replace both when they are the same age) applies to both spring types, but there are a few differences worth knowing.
Torsion springs
- Paired springs are sized as a set. On many two-spring doors, both springs are the same size. On some doors, the two springs are intentionally different sizes but chosen so their combined force matches the door. Either way, the pair is designed to work together.
- Winding direction matters. A two-spring system has a left-wound and a right-wound spring. Installing the wrong one is a safety hazard, and DASMA lists winding a torsion spring backwards as an installer safety issue.
- Turns and stretch must be set correctly. DASMA notes that too much torque can overload other counterbalance parts, too little can let the door drift down, and incorrect stretch can make coils rub and wear. Setting a new spring next to an old one makes this harder to get right.
Extension springs
- Always a matched pair. One spring per side, each carrying half the load. If one side is stronger than the other, the door lifts crooked and puts uneven stress on the cables and pulleys.
- Pulleys and cables usually get checked too. Extension systems rely on pulleys and lift cables on each side. Worn pulleys and frayed cables are common on older doors and are often replaced along with the springs.
- Safety containment cables are a must. A cable should run through the center of each extension spring so that if the spring breaks, the pieces are held instead of flying across the garage. If your extension springs do not have these cables, ask for them to be added.
- Consider a torsion conversion. Many homeowners with older extension systems choose to convert to torsion springs when both extension springs are due. Our torsion vs extension springs guide covers the pros and cons.
Safety Warning
Extension springs without safety containment cables can launch metal pieces across the garage when they break. If you have side-mounted springs and do not see a cable running through the middle of each spring, stay clear of the springs and the door’s path, and ask a technician to inspect the system.
Color codes can help a technician identify spring sizes, but they are only part of the story. DASMA’s spring color code sheet points out that color coding provides only partial identification, and that colors should be confirmed with physical measurements and door weight, especially on older installations. Our spring color code chart guide explains what the colors mean and why matching by color alone is risky.
Standard vs High-Cycle Replacement Springs
Once you decide to replace both garage door springs, the next decision is what kind of springs go back on the door. This is where you can make the biggest difference in how long you go before the next spring repair.
Standard residential torsion springs are commonly rated around 10,000 cycles. High-cycle springs use larger wire, a longer spring body, or both, so that each cycle puts less stress on the steel. Depending on the design, high-cycle springs are often rated for 20,000, 25,000, 50,000 cycles or more. The tradeoff is that larger springs cost more up front and need the right shaft length and hardware to fit.
| Feature | Standard Springs | High-Cycle Springs |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cycle rating | Around 10,000 cycles | Often 20,000 to 50,000+ cycles |
| Best for | Doors used a few times a day | Busy families, doors used as the main entry, rentals |
| Upfront cost | Lower | Higher |
| Long-term cost | More replacements over the life of the door | Fewer replacements and service calls |
| Wire and size | Smaller wire, shorter body | Larger wire, longer body, sized for lower stress |
| Fit | Fits nearly every door | Needs enough room on the torsion shaft; a technician confirms fit |
At Advanced Door, our springs are built for two to three times the cycle count of standard springs and are backed by a lifetime warranty. That is why our spring repairs are priced as a long-term solution rather than the cheapest possible quick fix. When you replace both springs with a matched high-cycle set, you reset the clock on the whole counterbalance system instead of buying a few more months.
Pro Tip
Ask any company you are comparing what cycle rating their springs carry and what the warranty actually covers. A low quote on standard springs with a short parts-only warranty is not the same job as a matched high-cycle set with a lifetime warranty. Our garage door warranty guide explains what to look for in the fine print.
For a deeper look at myths that come up around spring replacement, including the idea that one spring is always enough, see common myths about garage door spring replacement.
How Utah Weather Wears Out Garage Door Springs
Utah is hard on garage door springs. DASMA’s spring cycle life sheet specifically lists extreme heat or cold, frequent precipitation, and corrosive conditions as factors that can shorten spring life, and Utah has all of them depending on where you live.
| Region | What Stresses Springs | What to Watch For |
|---|---|---|
| Wasatch Front (Salt Lake, Davis, Weber, Utah counties) | Cold winters, freeze-thaw cycles, road salt and slush tracked in on vehicles | Rust on coils, squeaks or grinding from the spring area, spring breaks on cold mornings |
| Cache Valley and northern Utah | Long, very cold winters and heavy use of the garage as the main entry | Higher cycle counts, door feels heavy, slow or jerky lift in deep cold |
| Park City, Heber, and mountain areas | Snow, moisture, large temperature swings, and doors exposed to snowmelt | Corrosion, ice around the bottom seal adding strain, frequent cycling for gear and vehicles |
| Tooele County and areas near the Great Salt Lake | Salty, dusty air and wind | Surface rust and pitting on spring wire and hardware |
| St. George and southern Utah | Intense summer heat and dust | Dry, unlubricated springs, coil binding noise, doors left open on hot days |
Two practical takeaways for Utah homeowners:
- Rust shortens spring life. DASMA explains that rust reduces the effective area of the spring wire and creates corrosion pits where fatigue cracks can start. Wiping down springs is not a homeowner job, but keeping the garage drier and having springs lubricated during a tune-up helps. See our rust prevention guide.
- Keep the door closed when you can. DASMA recommends that doors in climates with extreme heat or cold be kept closed where possible, because doors left open for long periods expose the springs to more temperature, moisture, and air quality swings.
Utah Note
Fall is the best time to check your springs before a Utah winter. Spring breaks often show up on cold mornings, when a spring that was already near the end of its life finally lets go. If your springs are original and the door is more than several years old, our fall garage door maintenance checklist and winter garage door problems guide are worth a read now, not in January.
Why Spring Replacement Is a Professional Job
We get it. Spring kits are sold online, and there are plenty of videos that make the job look simple. But spring replacement is one of the few garage door repairs we strongly advise homeowners never to attempt. DASMA’s own spring color code sheet states that replacement of springs on garage doors should only be performed by a trained door systems technician.
Here is why:
- Stored energy. A wound torsion spring holds enough energy to lift the entire door. If a winding bar slips or a set screw is loosened at the wrong moment, that energy releases instantly.
- The unbroken spring is still loaded. On a two-spring door, the spring that did not break is still under tension. Many DIY injuries happen when someone works on the broken side without first safely unloading the other spring.
- Wrong parts are a hidden hazard. A spring that is the wrong size, wire, or wind direction may seem to work at first but can overload cables, make the door unsafe to lift by hand, or fail early.
- Cables and drums are part of the job. Spring replacement often reveals frayed cables or worn drums that also need attention. Spotting these takes experience.
Safety Warning
Never use screwdrivers or makeshift rods to wind or unwind torsion springs, never remove the bottom brackets or cable attachment points on a door with tension on it, and never stand in line with a spring that is under load. If a spring has broken, disconnect the opener from the door only if the door is fully closed and stays down, and do not try to lift the door by hand. Call a trained technician.
If you want to know which garage door repairs are safe to handle yourself, our DIY vs professional garage door repairs guide draws the line clearly, and can you replace garage door springs yourself goes deeper on the spring question specifically. If you need to get your car out before help arrives, read how to open a garage door manually first, including the warnings about broken springs.
What to Expect When You Replace Both Garage Door Springs
A proper two-spring replacement is more than swapping coils. Here is what a thorough job should include, so you know what you are paying for and can spot shortcuts.
- Safety first. The technician secures the door so it cannot move, disconnects the opener, and safely unwinds the tension from the unbroken spring before removing anything.
- Identify the right springs. The door’s size, weight, height, drum type, and track setup determine the correct springs. Good technicians measure and calculate rather than guessing from color or copying what was there, because the old springs may have been wrong to begin with.
- Install a matched pair. Both springs go on together with the correct wind direction, then are wound to the correct number of turns for the door.
- Inspect the rest of the counterbalance system. Cables, cable drums, end bearings, the center bearing plate, and the torsion shaft are checked for wear, fraying, or damage. Worn cables in particular are often replaced at the same time because they have also done every cycle.
- Balance the door. The door is tested by hand. It should lift smoothly, stay put when stopped partway, and not slam or fly up. Small adjustments are made until it is right.
- Lubricate and tune. Springs, bearings, hinges, and rollers are lubricated, and fasteners are checked. See our garage door lubrication guide for what this involves.
- Test the opener and safety features. The opener is reconnected and checked for force and travel settings, and the auto-reverse and photo-eye sensors are tested.
Most two-spring replacements are finished in a single visit when the right springs are on the truck. If your door has unusual dimensions, an enclosed spring system, or other damage, it may take longer. Our guide on how long garage door repair takes gives realistic timelines.
Pro Tip
Ask the technician to show you the old springs and any worn parts before they leave. A reputable company is happy to explain what failed and why. It also gives you peace of mind that what was replaced actually needed replacing.
Questions to Ask Before You Approve the Work
Spring replacement is one of the most common garage door repairs, which unfortunately also makes it a favorite for bait-and-switch pricing. A few good questions protect you either way.
- Is the quote for one spring or two? Make sure you are comparing the same job. A low phone quote for one spring can look very different from a matched pair on site.
- What cycle rating are the springs? Standard and high-cycle springs are very different products.
- What does the warranty cover, and for how long? Parts only, or parts and labor? Lifetime, or a year?
- Are cables, drums, or bearings included or extra? Ask what was inspected and what is recommended, and why.
- Can you show me why the surviving spring should be replaced? A good technician will explain age, rust, gaps, or wear in plain language.
- Is there a trip fee or after-hours charge? Emergency calls can carry different pricing. Get it in writing before work starts.
For more on spotting pressure tactics and fake low prices, see garage door repair scams and how to protect yourself and how to choose a garage door company in Utah. If your door broke after hours, our emergency garage door repair guide covers what to do while you wait.
Action Step
Write down the brand and color marks on your springs, the door size, and how many springs you have before you call for quotes. Read the quotes side by side: number of springs, cycle rating, warranty length, and what else is included. That is the fastest way to make a fair comparison.
How to Make Your New Garage Door Springs Last Longer
You cannot stop metal fatigue, but you can avoid the things that speed it up. These habits help new springs reach or exceed their rated life:
- Get an annual tune-up. A technician lubricates the springs and bearings, checks balance, and catches worn cables early. Our garage door tune-up guide explains what is included.
- Test balance a couple of times a year. Disconnect the opener with the door closed, lift the door halfway by hand, and see if it stays. If it drifts or feels heavy, call for an adjustment. Full steps are in our balance test guide.
- Do not add weight without a check. Paint, insulation kits, decorative hardware, and heavier windows add weight. DASMA notes that added weight can push a door past what its springs were designed for.
- Keep the door closed in extreme weather. Less exposure to heat, cold, and moisture means less corrosion.
- Keep the garage dry. Knock snow and slush off vehicles where you can, and fix leaks around the door. See our weatherproofing guide.
- Cut unnecessary cycles. If the family uses the garage as a revolving door, consider using the front door for quick trips. Every cycle counts.
- Listen for changes. New squeaks, a louder door, or a door that feels heavier can be early warnings. Our noise diagnosis guide helps you narrow it down.
For a full calendar of what to do and when, use our garage door maintenance schedule for Utah homeowners.
How Advanced Door Helps With Garage Door Spring Replacement
When a spring breaks, you want the door working again quickly and you want it done right. Our team provides:
- Honest diagnostics. We inspect both springs and tell you plainly whether replacing one or both makes sense for your door.
- Lifetime warranty springs. Built for two to three times the cycle count of standard springs, so you are not back in the same spot in a few years.
- Full counterbalance check. Cables, drums, bearings, and balance are inspected with every spring job.
- Single-to-double spring upgrades. When a two-spring setup is the better long-term choice for your door, we will explain why.
- Professional technicians. Trained, experienced, and equipped with the right tools for safe spring work.
- Free estimates, always. No pressure and no hidden fees.
Find your local team: Ogden garage door repair at (801) 430-9021, Logan and Cache Valley at (435) 363-4929, and Draper at (801) 967-8998. We also serve Provo and Utah County, Layton and Davis County, Park City and Summit County, St. George and Washington County, and the rest of the state. For an overview of everything we fix, see our Utah garage door repair guide.
Call (844) 971-3667 today for a free estimate. Current offers: $100 off any new door or 10% off any service call (offers cannot be combined).
FAQ: When to Replace Both Garage Door Springs
Do I need to replace both garage door springs if only one is broken?
If your door has two springs that were installed at the same time, yes, replacing both is the standard recommendation. Both springs have done the same number of cycles, so the surviving spring is usually close to failing too. Replacing both keeps the door balanced and avoids a second service call.
Is it dangerous to replace only one garage door spring?
It is not automatically dangerous if a trained technician does it and balances the door correctly. The risks are practical: the old spring is likely to break soon, the door can be harder to keep balanced, and uneven force adds wear to cables, drums, and the opener.
Can I open my garage door with one broken spring?
It is not safe to rely on it. The door has lost much of its counterbalance and can be very heavy, and the opener may strip gears or lose control of the door. Leave the door closed if you can and call a technician. If you must get a vehicle out, read the safety warnings in our manual opening guide first.
How long do garage door springs last?
Standard torsion springs are commonly rated around 10,000 cycles, where one cycle is one open and one close. That can mean many years for a lightly used door or only a few years for a busy family garage. High-cycle springs are built for a much longer cycle life.
Should extension springs always be replaced in pairs?
Yes. Extension springs work as a matched pair, one on each side of the door. A new spring on one side and an old spring on the other makes the door lift unevenly. Make sure safety containment cables run through both springs.
Why does my door have only one spring?
Many lighter doors and some builder-grade doors use a single torsion spring sized for the door’s weight. When that spring breaks, it can be a good time to ask whether a two-spring, high-cycle setup would last longer on your door.
Do both springs have to be the same size?
Not always. On many doors the two springs are identical, but some doors use two different sizes on purpose so their combined force matches the door. What matters is that the pair is calculated for your door’s weight and height and wound in the correct directions.
Can I replace garage door springs myself?
We strongly recommend against it. Torsion springs store enough energy to cause serious injury, and DASMA states that spring replacement should only be performed by a trained door systems technician. Call a professional for any spring work.
References: DASMA Technical Data Sheet #190, Factors Affecting Spring Cycle Life (how handling, installation, climate, and maintenance affect spring life) and DASMA Technical Data Sheet #171, Official Color Codes for Torsion and Extension Springs (spring identification, paired extension springs, and why spring replacement belongs with a trained technician).
Get a Free Estimate from Advanced Door
Broken garage door spring? Get an honest answer on one spring vs both, plus lifetime warranty springs installed by a local Utah team.
Serving Ogden, Salt Lake City, Provo, Park City, Logan, and all of Utah
Call for a free estimate. No pressure, no hidden fees.
Current offers: $100 off any new door or 10% off any service call
(Offers cannot be combined)
